Saturday, November 21, 2026

On Console Hype Breaking Through and NPCs in Games

I don't normally follow the console gaming scene any more.  The only gaming news site I still hit at least once a day is Massively.  However, if you follow any kind of news at all, you cannot help but have heard of GTA VI.  The reviews that started coming out for it this week were utterly breathless.  I would normally be quite skeptical.  However, I have now watched a few reviews, and I have to say it does seem like a noticable step up from GTA V, which is already a ridiculously expansive and immersive game.  

What has really struck me about GTA VI, is just how "real" it feels in the videos I have watched.  They seem to have really nailed the goal of having NPCs that feel like peaple, with lives to live whether you are watching them or not.  For example, this video really impressed me: 

Not that simulating the behavior of NPCs is at all new.  Agent Based models apparently go all the way back to the 1960s, and Pac Man is sometimes considered the first example of a Finite State Machine in a video game (more below).  However, that's not exactly the same as being able to interact with an NPC, unless running for your life in a simple maze counts.  It didn't take very long at all for PC roleplaying games to implement NPCs you could talk to, and by the late 80s pretty much any game that you could wander around in had at least some scripted interactions with NPCs.  

For example, I am currently playing the 30+ year old Phantasy Star** console RPG, and as primitive as it is you can still talk to any NPC you encounter.  You can even talk to a lot of random mobs if you care to, with "talk" being on the same line of menu options as "attack", "spell" and "item" in a fight.  However, in Phantasy Star there are only a few things a NPC can usually say, and in terms of their behavior it's strictly limited to "attack" or "don't attack."   I also remember some Goldbox games, like Pool of Radiance, having some pretty simple scripted dialigue trees where you could question some NPCs for information on a variety of topics. 

I actually really enjoy these simple interactions. I will literally talk to every man, woman and child I see when I am playing any RPG, online or off.  But in terms of "does any random NPC feel like a real person" the answer is a very definitive  "absolutely not" in most games. That is one of the major reasons I tend to favor MMOs over offline games.  Apart from individuals that are central to the story, most NPCs in a typical RPG are essentially mannequins with a tape-recorder attached to them. 

The first game that I am aware of to try and have NPCs determine their own behavior more organically was Ultima Online.  Apparently they spent a lot of time designing virtual ecology for the world.  Plants would grow, herbivores would eat the plants, and carnivores would eat the herbivores.  It actually sounds a lot like some Agent Based Models I have seen for ecological interactions, though by default most of those don't let you watch the individual agents and see what they are doing.  Regardless, the system in UO apparently didn't work very well, mainly becuase players did what they tend to do.

As far as trying for NPCs in a game that feel like they are following thier own script, the next example that comes to mind off the top of my head is the infamous Radient AI system of Elder Scrolls: Oblivion.   This entertaining retrospective describes how eventually they had to dial it back because walking into town and finding all the NPCs going Lord of the Flies over a loaf of bread was disruptive to the intended gameplay loops:

I have played Oblivion, and I also wouldn't say that the NPCs felt all that alive to me.  Though I did appreciate what the developers were trying to pull off.  

The video also describes how modern NPC behavioral systems work, and I have to say that they are much more sophisticated than I realized. Apparently modern games combine decision trees with "finate state machines" that alter NPC behavior depending on the "state" that it has been assigned (e.g., attack, flee, talk, recruit help).  The rules that govern transitions can be altered for various types of NPCs, allowing a limited number of states to generate varied NPC behavior that appears extremly idiosynchratic and context appropriate.   

A system like that is almost certainly in play in GTA VI.  However, what the game seems to do above and beyond that is vary NPC behavior in more subtle ways.  NPCs have conversations that have nothing to do with you, and on such a wide variety of topics that it's pretty obvious that LLMs must have been used to help generate a lot of the details.  Regardless of whether the underlying systems are all that innovative, GTA VI appears to have finally pushed NPC behavior over some threshold where it starts to feel much more realistic than what I am used to.  It's like Rockstar has crossed over some sort of behavioral uncanny valley.

Beyond that consideration, the level of graphical fidelity on display is also completely astounding to me.  To such a degree that I find myself wondering why on earth I would ever want a hypothetical PS6. GTA VI has to-the-horizon draw distances on extremely complex environments, absurd levels of detail up close (textures, lighting, physics, polys...all of it), and a locked in 30 fps on a baseline PS5.  We are talking a console with 16 gigs of integrated RAM and a graphics card that was released in 2018.  If GTA VI is what a developer can squeeze out of that system, why in the hell would we want to pay upwards of $1000 for more hardware?  

We obviously don't need more polys, better lighting or better textures any more.  We just need developers to be given enough time and resources to do what they are really capable of.  Apparently roughly a fifth of the staff of Rockstar has been working for the company for more than ten years.  Instead of treating their most experienced employees as eminintly replacable interns,  they actually valued their insitutional knowledge.  Funny how a team like that can blow your socks off. 

Overall, I have to admit I am a lot more intersted in an "on release" console game than I have been in a very long time.  At the same time, I am very much opposed to the $80 price point.*** My normal modus operundi is to wait until I can get some "all of it" edition for $20 before I even consider shelling out for a new game.  Hell, I have Read Dead Redemtion II here, and I haven't even been able to make time to stick it in my console.  So it really does not make any sense at all for me to take the plunge on GTA VI.  That said, I did clear off a quarter terabyte of space on my PS5 hardrive last night . . . just in case! 

*Agent Based Models are a type of mechanistic model used most often in Ecology and Epidimiology.  If you know anything at all about mechanistic models in epidimilology, you will have at least heard of the Susceptible Infectious Recovered (SIR) model that represents the proportion of a population that has transitioned between being infected by or recovered from a pathogen using equations very similar to those used to model the production of products in a chemical reaction.  You almost certainly encountered the kind of equation I am talking about in Chemistry class in high school, or perhaps as a freshman in college.  Rather than represent a system as a series of differential equations borrowed from chemistry, you directly model the behavior of individuals called Agents.  It would be like modelling the movement of individual molecules in a chemical reaction rather than just estimating the rate at which various reactions occur in aggregate.  You Agents in one of these models any rules you want, and then see what patterns emerge in the overall system after you let a bunch of them run around for hundreds or thousands of time steps.  They are designed to let you explicitly test for the influence of factors that are too complex to easilly represent using equations.  For example, one of the factors that they are often used for is to represent context dependent behavioral propensities.  Yet all of Agents I have encountered in these models are following much much simpler behavioral rules than those being used for NPCs by video game developers!  

**I'm playing it on GBA Advance (one of the flip screen models) that still works perfectly even after 20 years.  I am also playing on a cartridge that has Phatasy Star I, II and III on it.  The original Phatasy Star still holds up very well, with a 2d overworld and 3d dungeons.  It also has a few design oddities that never really made it into other more modern games.  The most noticable one is that you can try to talk to any monster you encounter.  If they decide to talk, that ends the encounter without a fight and you get a blurb of text similar to talking to a NPC in town.  There are even spells and items that let you talk to a wide variety of monsters than you can by default.  Unfortunately, II and III do not hold up as well.  Though III does have a very strange generation system where you start as characters that will be the grandparents of your current characters by the end of the game.

***As if $60 weren't bad enough!


No comments:

Post a Comment